Best Car Reviews - 2016 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet

Rate this article Choose 1-5 stars.

Introduction

The 2016 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet is an all-wheel-drive, open-top version of Porsche’s iconic rear-engined sports car, positioned for drivers who want year-round usability without giving up the classic 911 feel. In this model year, the Carrera 4S Cabriolet targets enthusiasts who value precision handling, premium build quality, and a convertible experience that still feels solid and serious. It stands out by blending everyday practicality for a high-performance car (2+2 seating and front trunk storage) with the traction benefits of 4-wheel drive and the involvement of a 7-speed manual.

Design and Exterior Features

The 2016 Carrera 4S Cabriolet keeps the 911’s unmistakable silhouette: a low nose, wide hips, and a sloping roofline that transitions into a clean rear deck once the soft top is raised. The all-wheel-drive “4” body brings a more planted look, with wider rear fenders and a broader stance than rear-wheel-drive counterparts. Up front, the styling remains purposeful rather than flashy, prioritizing aerodynamic cleanliness and a timeless profile that evolves gradually from generation to generation. The power-operated fabric roof preserves the classic cabriolet shape, and with the top down the car still looks cohesive rather than compromised.

Power-operated soft top designed for quick open-air driving
Wider rear bodywork on Carrera 4 models for a more aggressive stance
Signature 911 lighting and clean, aerodynamic proportions
Low-slung sports-car profile with a compact overall footprint

Interior and Comfort

Inside, the 2016 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet delivers a driver-focused cockpit with a premium, tightly assembled feel. Materials are upscale, with a mix of leather, quality plastics, and precise switchgear that emphasizes durability as much as luxury. The seating position is low and sporty, with supportive front seats that work well for both long drives and spirited cornering. The rear seats are best treated as occasional seating for small passengers or as extra storage, which helps explain why the EPA classifies the 911 in the “minicompact” category despite its premium pricing. With the roof up, the cabin remains refined for a performance convertible, and with the roof down, wind management is helped by available deflectors and smart interior shaping.

Driver-centric layout with a classic multi-gauge instrument cluster feel
Supportive front seats suited to daily driving and performance use
2+2 seating: small rear seats that often function as extra cargo space
High-quality materials and solid, premium switchgear

Performance and Handling

Power comes from a 3.8-liter flat-six (6 cylinders) with direct injection (SIDI), paired here with a 7-speed manual transmission and 4-wheel drive for improved traction in poor conditions and stronger all-season confidence. Output is rated at 400 horsepower and 325 lb-ft of torque, giving the Cabriolet the kind of immediate response and high-rev character many enthusiasts associate with naturally aspirated-era Carreras. Acceleration is strong for the segment, and manufacturer-estimated 0–60 mph performance is listed at 4.5 seconds for this configuration, though real-world results can vary with conditions and driver technique. Handling is a defining strength: the car feels precise, stable at speed, and unusually usable for a high-performance convertible, with steering and chassis tuning that reward smooth inputs. Fuel efficiency is respectable for a premium-gas sports car: EPA figures commonly list 18 mpg city, 26 mpg highway, and 21 mpg combined, which is approximately 13.1 L/100 km city, 9.0 L/100 km highway, and 11.2 L/100 km combined. Real-world consumption can be higher with short trips, heavy traffic, or enthusiastic driving, and a combined figure around 14.2 L/100 km can be plausible in those conditions.

3.8L flat-six with direct injection (SIDI) and a high-revving character
400 hp and 325 lb-ft for strong, linear performance
4-wheel drive improves traction and confidence in mixed weather
7-speed manual adds driver involvement, especially on back roads
EPA-rated efficiency around 11.2 L/100 km combined (approx.)

Technology and Connectivity

The 2016 Carrera 4S Cabriolet focuses on performance-first usability while still offering the essentials expected in a premium car. Infotainment centers around a touchscreen interface with navigation and Bluetooth connectivity, designed to be operated without distracting from driving. Audio upgrades and comfort technology were a major part of Porsche ownership in this era, and many cars are optioned with premium sound, added convenience features, and driver-assistance add-ons. It is also a model-year context where modern smartphone mirroring is not as comprehensive as newer cars, so buyers often prioritize factory navigation quality, Bluetooth stability, and the overall ergonomics of the center stack.

Touchscreen-based infotainment with navigation and Bluetooth
USB/media integration for everyday usability
Available premium audio upgrades depending on configuration
Optional driver-assistance features depending on equipment package

Safety Features

Safety engineering in the 2016 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet blends traditional performance-car fundamentals (strong brakes, stability systems) with modern occupant protection. Standard equipment includes antilock brakes, traction control, stability control, and multiple airbags including side airbags for the front occupants. As a convertible, it also incorporates rollover protection designed to deploy when needed. Crash-test ratings can be difficult to cite for this exact model and configuration because major public programs do not always publish widely referenced ratings for low-volume sports cars in every trim and body style, so shoppers should focus on equipment, tire condition, and maintenance history alongside any available recall and safety information.

Antilock braking system (ABS) with traction and stability control
Front airbags and front-seat side airbags for added protection
Convertible-specific rollover protection system
Available parking aids and camera systems depending on options

Pricing and Variants

When new, the 2016 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S 2dr Convertible AWD with the 7-speed manual carried a starting MSRP of $117,530 in the U.S. before options, and options can raise real transaction prices substantially. The broader 2016 911 range spans many variants, but within the Carrera family the key steps around this model include the Carrera 4 Cabriolet below it and higher-performance or more track-focused trims above it. Compared with rivals, the Carrera 4S Cabriolet competes less on raw value and more on balance: it is typically more precise and all-round usable than many high-power convertibles, while remaining less exotic (and often less expensive) than mid-engine or supercar alternatives.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Exceptionally balanced handling with strong everyday drivability
All-wheel drive adds real all-season confidence for a sports car
Engaging 7-speed manual option for enthusiasts
High-quality interior materials and impressive build solidity
Iconic 911 styling with a timeless convertible profile

Cons

Options add up quickly and can push pricing far beyond the base MSRP
Rear seats are small and mainly useful for storage or small passengers
Running costs (tires, brakes, service) are premium-level
Ride quality can feel firm on rough roads, especially with sport-oriented setups
Infotainment and smartphone integration feel dated versus newer models

Maintenance and Common Issues

Ownership costs for a Porsche 911 are typically higher than mainstream vehicles, and a widely cited estimate for average annual maintenance and repairs is around $1,072 per year, though real costs vary heavily by mileage, driving style, local labor rates, and how proactively the car is maintained. For the 2016 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet and the broader 991-era ownership experience, commonly discussed owner-reported and shop-observed issues often include cooling-system leaks or coolant loss, occasional electrical or battery-related quirks (especially with infrequent use), infotainment or module glitches, suspension noises or wear items as mileage climbs, and convertible-top wear or hydraulic/operational issues on Cabriolet models. The most important buying advice is to prioritize complete service records, a thorough pre-purchase inspection, and evidence of proper tire and brake maintenance.

Rating

Overall rating: 9.0/10. Design: 9.5/10. Comfort: 8.5/10. Performance: 9.5/10. Technology: 8.0/10. Safety: 8.5/10. The 2016 Carrera 4S Cabriolet earns its score by delivering a rare blend of sports-car engagement, high-end quality, and real-world usability, with the main deductions coming from cost of ownership and aging tech by modern standards.

User Reviews and Feedback

Owner feedback patterns for the 2016 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet tend to emphasize how complete the car feels: thrilling when pushed, but still comfortable enough to use regularly. Many owners appreciate the confidence of all-wheel drive and the sense of mechanical connection from the manual transmission. Complaints most often revolve around expensive options and maintenance, the limited practicality of the rear seats, and the reality that tires and brakes are consumables that can add up quickly. Convertible owners commonly highlight the enjoyment of top-down driving with surprisingly solid road manners, while also acknowledging that long-term upkeep is best handled with careful servicing and prevention-minded maintenance.

Praise for steering precision and confidence-inspiring handling
High satisfaction with build quality, materials, and long-distance comfort for a sports car
Frequent notes that options and upkeep can be expensive
Appreciation for all-wheel-drive stability in mixed weather
Convertible enjoyment balanced against additional top-related maintenance considerations

Best Cars in This Category

2016 Jaguar F-Type R Convertible
2016 Mercedes-Benz AMG GT S
2016 Audi R8 Spyder
2016 Chevrolet Corvette Stingray Convertible
2016 Nissan GT-R Premium

Summary

The 2016 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet is best suited for drivers who want a premium sports car that can realistically be used often, not just saved for perfect weather. It combines convertible excitement with the added security of 4-wheel drive and a manual transmission option that keeps the experience involving and authentic. While it is not the cheapest way into serious performance, its blend of precision, quality, and everyday usability makes it one of the most appealing open-top sports cars of its era for buyers who value long-term satisfaction as much as speed.